Empathy: it's harder than it looks

Today at homeless outreach the doctor had to cap the list at ten patients. He had an important meeting and couldn't let the clinic run long (which it often does). Which means that I had to turn people away. Which sucks.

One patient I've known for over a year said "I should be on that list. I was here early but the list wasn't out and then I had to leave."

"I'm sorry, but he can't take more than ten patients today. How are you doing?"

"Not good." Tears. "I wish somebody'd just drive up and shoot me."

This patient has a long history of depression along with a chronic medical condition. Her husband died over a decade ago (murdered, I believe). She's got addiction issues. She looked miserable this morning. And so I decided to say exactly the wrong thing, although it felt honest and true when it came out of my mouth.

"I know how you feel."

I meant I know depression, I know suicidal feelings. I know how lonely it feels. But of course I don't know how it feels to be her (or anyone else, for that matter). So maybe that wasn't the best choice of words. The worst part, though, was realizing that what I'd said had the unintended consequence of appearing to minimize her situation.

"No you don't. You're young. You don't know how I feel." By this point she was bawling and kept repeating her death wish as she walked away. Some people overheard her and started laughing at her as she walked by. (She's been around for years and they've all heard it before, although I still wanted to tell them to leave her the fuck alone.)

However, I was too busy feeling like a total ass.

There's not much the doctor could do for her, honestly. She has all her prescriptions and she was in the clinic last week. I think she just wanted to be around him. He's a very warm, caring, spiritual person and a lot of patients just like talking to him. He makes them feel good.

I feel like I'm going to be good at that part of medicine someday. But what this interaction made me realize was that I have to make more of an effort to understand how the patients see me (as opposed to how I see myself). She looked at me this morning and saw that I was well-dressed and healthy and young and on the path to becoming a physician. I see myself as scared and unsure of myself and as someone who continues to deal with depression and anxiety. But even if I could get her to see me as I see myself, that's not really helpful to her. Or not nearly as helpful as being someone who can be a constant, reassuring presence in her life (like the doctor).

Basically, she doesn't need me to feel her pain. The doctor has a great line for patients who have overwhelming personal histories: "What can I do for you today?" I've heard him say that dozens of times, and it's usually at the point that I'm starting to tear up while listening to the patient's story. And tearing up isn't exactly helpful. The doctor knows he can only do so much, though, and so he tries to keep the patients focused on specific things that can be done to improve their situations.

He seems to have a pretty good grip on the role he can play in these peoples' lives. It's something I'll have to grow into slowly. Right now I still feel so much closer to the role of victimized patient than caring physician.

Labels: Healthcare

 

posted Tuesday, May 22, 2007

1 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

aw (that's "aw," as in, "i empathize with you", not "aw, how cute"). it's going to take years for you to feel confident and to have the "right words" at the tip of your tongue when you need them. but the fact that you worry about how you're perceived and the impact your words can have - positive or negative - indicates that you've already begun the process of shaping yourself into a sensitive, conscientious, and kind physician.

12:01 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Lean Joe is
    a 34 year-old pediatrics resident living in Los Angeles; Drew's husband; a former Hollywood assistant and reality television story editor; a Dolly Parton fan, not actually named Joe; "lean" is debatable.
Current Favorites
  • Amanda
  • Charlie Rose
  • Crooks & Liars
  • Dancing Brave
  • Huffington Post
  • Hulu
  • My Marathon Training Schedule
  • (as though you care)
  • NYT
  • The Peculiar One
  • Perez Hilton
  • PITA baby
  • Rosie O'Donnell
  • Towleroad
  • Washington Post
Why Don't I Know This?
  • Define penumbra.
  • Why is gold a precious metal?
  • What is calamari?
  • How old is the universe?
  • What is the current troop level in Afghanistan?
  • The difference between an MRI and a CAT scan.
  • What's the story of Pygmalion?
  • What's the point of having superdelegates?
  • What's a bridleway?
  • What's the difference between a "plurality" and a "majority"?
  • Define penury.
  • Where, exactly, is the Horn of Africa?
  • What is redlining?
  • Define encomium.
  • What is a Maginot Line?
  • What were the seven liberal arts?
  • Define ballast.
  • Define tumbrel.
  • Where is Azerbaijan?
  • Where does the word hermeneutics come from?
  • The idea that low levels of serotonin cause depression is still just a theory.
  • Define frisson.
  • Who is Jonathan Safran Foer?
  • Who funds the interstate highway system?
  • What's the difference between analog and digital signals?
  • How many damn revolutions did France have? 1, 2, 3...
  • What is the Alhambra?
  • Where is Armenia?
  • Why is it called the "Stockholm Syndrome"?
  • Where does the idiom "an albatross around your neck" come from?
  • What does realpolitik mean?
  • What's in gin? (mmm... gin.)
  • How does California generate electricity?
  • Who sits on a grand jury?
  • Where is Bulgaria?
  • How do point spreads work?
    Previous Posts
    • Deadly toothache
    • Itinerary
    • Sorry, Dolly Fan
    • Health Insurance
    • Free Dog
    • Weekly Dolly Video
    • What I'm doing
    • 100% Phildelphia
    • Someone Vacuum this Bed
    • Weekly Dolly Video

    Powered by Blogger